Five Retirement Asset Allocation Pitfalls to Avoid
No other factor will have a bigger impact on your portfolio's success or failure than your asset-allocation plan.
The size of your retirement nest egg and the pace at which you plan to spend it—your withdrawal rate—are the key determinants of the viability of your financial plan for retirement.
But when it comes to your actual investment portfolio, no other factor will have a bigger impact on your portfolio's success or failure than your asset-allocation plan—your mix of stocks, bonds, and cash. Be too meek and you heighten the risk of a shortfall; maintain a too aggressive portfolio and you run the risk of incurring a bigger loss than you could reasonably recoup over your in-retirement time horizon.
Although it is hard to go terribly wrong with a simple 50% stock/50% bond mix, there are not any one-size-fits-all asset-allocation frameworks for retirement portfolios. An individual's age, the presence of other income-producing retirement assets (like pensions or Social Security), and spending rate, among other factors, can all dictate higher or lower equity or bond weightings.
As you evaluate your retirement portfolio, making sure you are sidestepping the following asset-allocation pitfalls is a good way to steer your portfolio in the right direction.
1. Being Too Conservative
Survey market experts' outlooks for the stock and bond markets, and you will notice that true equity bulls are in short supply. However, low starting yields argue against compelling returns from bonds over the next decade; take-home returns from bonds may be barely positive once inflation is factored in. Cash looks like an even worse bet from the standpoint of preserving purchasing power. That means that on a long-term real basis, seemingly safe securities are not all that safe.
The fact that most retirees need to hold a significant position in stocks is not a terribly comforting message for the risk-averse. But stocks give retired investors a fighting chance at outgunning inflation, something cash and high-quality bonds will be hard-pressed to do. That explains why most all-in-one investments geared toward retirees maintain healthy allocations to stocks.
2. Confusing Risk Tolerance with Risk Capacity
Many retirees and pre-retirees are way out on the other extreme: They are equity true believers, and do not see much of a role for anything but stocks in their portfolios. This describes many baby boomer investors. They have had a good experience with stocks over their investing careers, whereas bonds' prospects seem downright questionable given the headwinds of higher interest rates.
But it is important to not confuse your ability to tolerate risk—in this case, not getting too bugged about equity losses—with risk capacity, a much more important consideration. Risk capacity refers to what sorts of losses you can handle without having to meaningfully alter your plans. For retirees who encounter big losses in equity portfolios that they are actively spending from, the net effect is that less of their portfolios are in place to recover when stocks eventually do. This can be a big problem for a portfolio's longevity, especially if those losses occur early in the retiree's time horizon.
That is the reason that most in-retirement asset-allocation frameworks call for holding significant shares of the portfolio in cash and bonds to meet in-retirement living expenses in years when stock returns are poor. They also call for reducing equities in a retirement portfolio over time to reflect the fact that risk capacity shrinks with an individual's time horizon.
3. Ignoring Your Behavioral Track Record
Even as risk capacity should supersede considerations about your comfort level with risk, it is important to take your past investing behavior into account when determining your portfolio's asset allocation. Do you have a track record of running for the exits when the going gets rough for your stock portfolio? If so, consider nudging your equity allocation down a bit and your cash and bond cushion up relative to recommended allocations for investors at your same life stage to improve the odds that you will stick with the program in periods of volatility. Just remember that a more-conservative
portfolio may necessitate changes elsewhere in your plan—for example, the lower your equity weighting, the lower your withdrawal rate should generally be.
4. Not Factoring in All Income Sources
The reason that making one-size-fits-all asset-allocation recommendations is so difficult is that no one but you knows all of the pieces of your financial life. (This is why a financial advisor can be so valuable, in that he or she can make recommendations based on your own variables.) One of the biggest factors that can affect an individual's asset allocation, both leading up to and during retirement, is the presence of other in-retirement income sources, above and beyond what the portfolio will supply. This includes sources such as Social Security, pensions, and fixed annuities.
If those stable income sources will supply most or all of your needed income in retirement, your risk capacity is such that you should be able to withstand a higher equity weighting, at least in theory. Retirees with limited stable income sources, by contrast, will need to be conservative with the parts of their portfolios they will spend within the next several years. They will need higher weightings in cash and bonds.
5. Not Factoring in Nonretirement Goals
In a related vein, successful asset-allocation plans should take into account other goals—in addition to providing cash flows during retirement—that you have for your portfolio later in life.
A common example of such a goal would be to leave assets behind for children, grandchildren, or charity; individuals for whom this is a priority will generally want to maintain a more equity-heavy posture in their long-term portfolios than individuals who are not aiming to make bequests. Not only do they have a greater incentive to make their portfolios grow, but they also have a longer time horizon for their assets. Of course, some retirees view their homes as the chief asset that would eventually be sold to benefit their heirs; a desire to make that type of bequest would not have an impact on the positioning of the investment portfolios.
Contact your Wintrust Wealth Management financial professional to review your asset allocation and address any questions you may have.
© Morningstar 2019. All Rights Reserved. Used with permission.
Where will your financial journey take you? A Financial Advisor helps you navigate the terrain, avoid pitfalls, and keep you on track to achieve your financial goals.